Marcus is a straight guy and we had our gal pal Ashley standing by while I ate his beefy ass and swallowed his load!

14:29

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

JD's a shy straight guy and he lets me blow him! (2K)

Man Amateur

10:38

The best new bareback amateur clips

Douglas Smith fucked raw by River

Amateur Bareback

1:20:09

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Double Header: Chad x2, Jebb x2!

Amateur Blowjob

1:45:47

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Orgyfest! 14 hot straight guys in 4 full movies!!

Amateur Bareback

0:57

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Axe and Tyler Fuck

Twink Amateur

14:34

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Kyle's a Straight Hillbilly & Dylan's a Cage Fighter

Twink Amateur

2:26:16

The Great Canadian Male

Straight head part 3

Man Amateur

24:40

Gay Diaries

Handsome man gets ass licked and screwed by his friend

Man Big Cock

1:18:58

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Gettin' Some!! With Michael, Ben & Smoke, Marcus, Johnny & Brock, Dalton in 2K!

Amateur Blowjob

1:18:58

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Boys will be Toys - and there's a lot of them in this one!

Twink Amateur

42:15

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Playtime with James. Party with Eric Johnny & Ry

Twink Amateur

43:26

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Lucas' 1st Rimjob / Lucas & Nitro!

Twink Amateur